Chart 1     [† means all children believed found, ‡ means death is computed at 112 years]

Penny, Oliver E (b:1833-1834)(d:)
. . . . .Penny, Charles J (b:1864)(d:1918)[with: (unknown), Rachel]
. . . . . . . . . .Penny, Robert (b:1895-1894)(d:)[with: Hawley, Amanda Josephine]